You’ve had the email written for three days. It’s still sitting in your drafts. Maybe it’s the follow-up with someone you met at an event, the offer you keep meaning to make, or the call you swear you’ll make tomorrow. Every time you open it, a voice starts up. Who do you think you are? What if they say no?
So you start overthinking it and trying to get it just right. It ends up taking so much more time than it should.
If you’re trying to stop overthinking, here’s what I want you to know. You feel like you never have enough time, but it’s actually a challenge with your capacity. And hesitation never costs you just one thing. It compounds into missed opportunities, drained energy, lost confidence, and less presence for what matters most.
This episode is a talk I gave on the InvestHer Con stage in Phoenix. I share the phone call that changed how I show up, and the Leadership Rhythm I use to move from overthinking to action: Focus Out, Focus On, and Focus In. You’ll also get five categories for sorting everything on your plate, so you know what’s yours to carry and what isn’t.
In this episode on how to stop overthinking, you’ll discover:
- Why hesitation never costs you just one thing, and how it compounds
- The difference between real threats and perceived threats like judgment, rejection, and imposter syndrome
- Why imposter syndrome doesn’t go away as you grow, and what to build instead
- The Leadership Rhythm: Focus Out, Focus On, and Focus In
- Five categories for everything on your plate: lead, delegate, outsource, grow, and release
- Why cheap help can’t deliver a result you can’t create yourself (and the same goes for AI)
- Why taking care of yourself is the first thing you cancel, and the one thing no one can do for you
- The one question that helps you stop overthinking and start showing up
How do I stop overthinking decisions in my business?
Start by changing the question you’re asking. Overthinking usually runs on one question: what will people think of me? That question keeps you calculating risk, polishing, and waiting until it feels safe. Try a different one. Who needs me to show up right now? Every business exists to serve people, and you can’t think about them and worry about yourself at the same time. When your attention goes to the people you serve, your mission starts to outweigh your fear. It also helps to name what the hesitation is costing you. It’s rarely one thing. Overthinking compounds into missed opportunities, drained energy, lost momentum, and less presence with the people you love. Then look at your capacity. A tired, overloaded mind hesitates more because it can’t reach clear judgment. Clear your plate and rest your body, and decisions get faster.
How do I decide what to delegate, outsource, or keep doing myself?
Sort every task, responsibility, and idea into one of five categories. Lead is what you’re skilled at, love doing, or are the only one who can do. That’s yours to own. Delegate is work you’re effective at, but it isn’t the best use of your time, or you can’t stand doing it. Hand it to your team and lead them through it. Outsource is work you’re not effective at and that would cost too much time or money to grow into. Hire an expert who becomes responsible for the result. Grow is a skill you don’t have yet but need for where you’re going. Give yourself room to practice with grace. Release is anything that comes off your plate, either for good or parked for now. If you keep hitting the same plateau, look at your Grow list. That’s often where your capacity is capped.
Why does delegating or outsourcing keep failing for me?
When delegating or outsourcing doesn’t work, it usually comes down to one of two things. The first is a mismatch between the person’s skill level and what you expect from them. The second is a lack of vetting before you bring them on. Here’s the loving hard truth. You can’t hire cheap help to create a result you can’t create yourself, because you won’t know how to lead that person. If you know how to do the work, delegate it and coach them through it. If you don’t, outsource it to someone who already has the skill and will own the result, and be willing to pay for that skill. The same goes for AI. It pulls from common knowledge, and it can hand you advice that sounds right and isn’t. Don’t spend hours training it to do work you can’t judge yourself.
Does imposter syndrome ever go away?
In my experience, no. I’ve sat at tables with leaders managing multi-million-dollar portfolios who still worry they’re unworthy, unqualified, and one decision away from being found out as a fraud. The portfolio gets bigger, and the worry comes along. That can sound discouraging, but it’s freeing once you see it. If more success doesn’t make imposter syndrome go away, you don’t have to wait for it to leave before you act. What you can do is build the capacity to manage your mind, so the voice is there but it doesn’t run the show. It helps to know what imposter syndrome is doing. It’s your mind trying to keep you safe from judgment and rejection. Those feel like real threats, even though they’re perceived ones. Seeing that difference gives you room to choose your next move.
Why is taking care of myself the first thing I cancel when I get busy?
Taking care of yourself is usually the first thing to go. Sleep, movement, time with the people you love, and everything that fills your cup get pushed aside. It’s the one place where you don’t have to inconvenience anyone or ask permission, so it feels like the easiest place to borrow from. It’s also the one thing you can’t outsource. No one else can sleep for you or move your body for you. Here’s why it matters for your business. You can talk yourself into almost anything, but you can’t mindset your way past exhaustion. When you’re worn out, your protective patterns get louder, you lose access to good judgment, and you jump into things you normally wouldn’t. Protecting your rest protects your decisions.
The phone call that changed how I show up
It was a Thursday in early May 2020, just after lunch, when my phone rang. It was my best friend, Annemarie. I’ve known her since we were six. She’s family. It wasn’t a normal time for her to call, so I skipped the niceties. “Are you okay?”
She wasn’t. She had just come back from the gynecologist. She had stage four cervical cancer.
If you’ve ever taken a call like that, you know how fast your mind spins. I asked her what the plan was. She said, “I’m going to fight it.”
Everything in me wanted to get in the car, drive two hours north to Cleveland, and fix it. I couldn’t. We were in the middle of the pandemic, my husband was a first responder, and I couldn’t risk bringing anything to her.
So I did the only thing I could think of. If she was going all in on her healing, I would bring that same all-in energy to everything I did. I went all in on my business, and I served the people it serves like their lives depended on it.
Here’s what I learned. When someone you love is fighting for their life, you stop worrying about what other people think of you. You stop overthinking. You stop procrastinating and trying to get it perfect. You show up.
What hesitation is costing you
Take a second and ask yourself what hesitation is costing you. Is it opportunity and money left on the table? Time and energy spent overthinking? Confidence and momentum lost to playing it safe? Fulfillment and presence for what matters most?
When I asked a room full of business owners, the answers split almost evenly. That tells me hesitation doesn’t cost you one thing. It compounds.
Real threats and perceived threats
Annemarie’s diagnosis was a real threat. So is a natural disaster that levels your home, or a market that crashes overnight. Real threats can wipe you out. They deserve every feeling you feel and all the attention you give them.
Most of what stops us is something else. Perceived threats.
The first one is judgment. When I asked the room what judgment sounds like in their heads, the answers came fast. Who do you think you are? I’m not good enough. I should know better. You don’t know what you’re doing. You don’t have enough money for that. Sound familiar?
The second is rejection. Think about the email you didn’t send, the call you didn’t make, or the room you didn’t walk into, all because of one word: no. When I asked what that cost people, they named self-trust, connections, confidence, and self-respect. That last one stings. Every time you don’t follow through for yourself, you send yourself a message that you can’t depend on you.
The third is imposter syndrome. Let me tell you something about it. It never goes away. I’ve sat at tables with leaders managing multi-million-dollar portfolios who still worry they’re one decision away from being found out as a fraud. The portfolio grows. The worry stays. What you can grow is your capacity to manage your mind, so imposter syndrome doesn’t run the show.
Why your mind treats judgment like a bear
Here’s what’s happening underneath. Your mind doesn’t always know the difference between a perceived threat and a real one. In the Immunity to Change® method, developed by Harvard faculty Dr. Robert Kegan and Dr. Lisa Lahey, this protective system is called the psychological immune system.
Here’s how I explain it. You’re loading new programs onto an outdated operating system. You say you want to send the email and make the offer, and you mean it. Underneath, you may have a hidden competing commitment, like never being seen as someone who doesn’t know what they’re doing. That’s one foot on the gas and the other on the brake.
Driving both is a big assumption. That’s a rule your unconscious made up about how the world works and how you exist in it, designed to keep you safe. It might sound like, “If people see me make a mistake, they’ll stop trusting me.” Your system isn’t broken. It’s doing its job perfectly. As a Certified Immunity to Change® Coach, I help clients see that assumption clearly, then run small, safe tests that show when it applies and when it doesn’t.
“Every time you don’t follow through for yourself, you are sending yourself a message: I can’t depend on you.”
The Leadership Rhythm
So how do you stop overthinking when your mind is doing exactly what it was built to do? I use the Leadership Rhythm. It has three parts.
Focus Out is who you serve. It gives you direction. Focus On is how you build. It creates momentum. Focus In is how you sustain it. It’s your restoration.
If you’re a doer, you’re probably great at Focus On. If someone on your team drops the ball, you’ll just do it yourself. The other two tend to slide. So let’s take them one at a time, starting with direction.
Focus Out: who needs you to show up
Time to let my petty human out for a minute. That’s what I call the catty version of me. You probably have one too.
You know someone who’s less knowledgeable and less experienced than you. Maybe you’ve even questioned whether what they do is ethical. And yet they’re doing more deals, raising more capital, and building more wealth than you are. You’ve had some feelings about it.
I see you. It’s frustrating. And that judgment is a perfect example of the voice we just talked about. It’s a very human thing to do, and it’s keeping you stuck. They’re just not afraid to get messy and make mistakes. While you protect yourself from the same judgment you just made of them, you’re protecting yourself from people who were never going to do business with you anyway.
Meanwhile, the people who need you are choosing someone else. They chose the person who was available. The more qualified, more experienced person who cared about them was at home overthinking it.
Your life matters to other people. When you get that, you stop calculating risk, and your mission to serve starts to outweigh your fear. So when you find yourself spinning, focus out. Think about the people you serve. It’s the fastest way I know to stop overthinking, because you can’t think about them and worry about yourself at the same time.
“When you stop thinking about what will people think of me, and you start thinking about who needs me to show up right now, you show up.”
Focus On: what belongs on your plate
Focus On is where most of us live. It’s also where the questions pile up. What’s my responsibility? What can I trust someone else to do? What can I let go of, when I could do it faster myself?
I sort everything on a plate into five categories: every task, every responsibility, and every new idea. My multi-passionate entrepreneurs, this one is for you.
Lead is what you’re skilled at, love doing, or are the only one who can do. This is where you shine. You own it.
Delegate is work you’re effective at, but it isn’t the best use of your time, or you hate doing it. It goes to your team, and you lead them through it.
Outsource is work you’re not effective at and that would cost too much time or money to grow into. This is expert work. You hire it out, and that person becomes responsible for the result.
Grow is what you’re not skilled at yet but where you’re going. This is your edge. Give yourself room to practice with grace. Perfectionists, I know this one is hard. Many of you want to emerge already perfect, so you keep putting Grow off. That’s why you keep hitting the same plateau. Mistakes are part of the process.
Release is what comes off your plate. Some things leave for good because they were never yours. Others just get parked. In a mentorship program I coach in, I tell members they can only start one new thing per quarter. They hate me for it, then love me for it later. Trying too many new things at once burns through your brain space. Mandy McAllister and I talked about what that brain space is worth in EP119: The Framework That Will Change How You Look at Every Income Stream.
When delegating and outsourcing go wrong
If you’ve been burned by delegating or outsourcing, you’re not alone. When it doesn’t work, it usually comes down to one of two things. The person’s skill level didn’t match what you expected. Or they weren’t vetted well.
Here’s a loving hard truth. You can’t hire cheap help to create a result you can’t create yourself, because you don’t know how to lead that person. If you know how to get the result, delegate it and coach. If you don’t, hire someone who does, and be willing to pay for the skill. I walk through these choices in EP109: Outsource, Delegate, or Do It Yourself? How to Get Your Time Back. Zen Jenn and I also dig into why cheap help so often costs you twice in EP121: When to Hire, and Why Cheap Help Often Costs You Twice.
The same goes for AI. AI pulls from common knowledge, including a lot of fluff and theory people have fed into it. More than once, someone has told me what their AI said to do, and it was the opposite of what I’d coach them to do. If you know how to create the result, AI can help. If you don’t, don’t spend hours training it. Hire someone who knows the work.
Why letting go feels unsafe
If you’re having a hard time taking something off your plate that isn’t yours, something in the background is making it feel unsafe. That’s a leadership piece, and it’s a capacity you can build.
Accountability is uncomfortable for a lot of us. You don’t want to tell someone they’re not doing their job. You don’t want to be the meanie. Or it just isn’t done your way. But if everything has to be done your way, the people around you have no room to grow or breathe. You’re suffocating them. We do it by accident, because we’re trying to stay safe. That’s the psychological immune system at work, and it’s exactly the kind of competing commitment I help clients map.
One client I worked with kept jumping in and taking over work that belonged to their team. If something wasn’t getting done fast enough, or the way they wanted it done, or they felt they hadn’t given someone enough lead time, they took it back. At the core of it was a fear. If they gave feedback or asked for something that might seem unreasonable, they would become just like the nightmare clients they used to work with.
That fear was their big assumption. Taking the work back kept them from ever becoming that person. It also kept them doing work that was never theirs to carry.
Focus In: the first thing you cancel
Focus In is sleep, movement, relationships, travel, and the joys of your life. It’s everything that fills your cup. And it’s the first thing doers throw out the window when things get busy.
Here’s why. It’s the one place you don’t have to inconvenience anyone. You don’t have to ask permission or feel like a burden. It’s easy to steal from yourself because it feels like the one thing you own. It’s also the one thing you can’t outsource. No one else can sleep for you or exercise for you.
I have my human, and I have my higher self. My higher self doesn’t love taking care of my human. She thinks my human is kind of a pain in the butt. While I was writing this talk, I realized I was two years overdue for my gynecology exam. I was writing a speech about my best friend’s cervical cancer, and I had canceled on myself. (I’m caught up now.) If that doesn’t show you how easy it is, I don’t know what will.
Borrowing from tomorrow’s health is like playing Russian roulette. If you don’t have your health, you can’t enjoy the wealth and freedom you’ve built.
“It’s really easy to steal from ourselves because it’s the one thing we think we own, and it is the one thing you cannot outsource.”
You can’t mindset your way past exhaustion
Most of us are good at mindset. We can talk ourselves into almost anything. Do it scared. We’ve got this. But you can mindset yourself right into exhaustion, and a tired mind is difficult to manage.
Your subconscious starts running circles around you, trying to protect you. It’s well intentioned and completely ruthless. That’s your psychological immune system running on an empty tank. You lose access to good judgment, and you jump into things you normally wouldn’t. Taking care of your body is one of the most important things you can do for your business.
Life is right now
When you live the Leadership Rhythm, you hesitate less. Focus Out gives you direction. Focus On gives you momentum. Focus In gives you restoration. With a clearer mind, you make faster decisions, and you start living like life is happening right now, because it is.
I know what it costs to skip this. Two weeks before my due date with my daughter, I was on all fours under one of my mobile homes, trying to keep my belly off the ground while I shut off the water pouring out from under the laundry room. Four other adults stood around watching. I delivered my daughter four days later. I can laugh about it now. But that was a capacity problem. I hadn’t built a business with the right people in place. The Capacity Decision Guide is what I wish I’d had before I became a mother.
So here’s my ask. Write down one thing you’ve been hesitating on. One conversation, one decision, one step toward your future self. Then take action on it today. Not tomorrow. Not next week. Today, because life is right now.
What Annemarie taught me
Annemarie fought hard, with all the grace, humor, and kindness she had, right up to the end. I did make that two-hour drive to see her. She passed away on January 5, 2021.
That same day, I was scheduled to coach in a mentoring program that contracts me for coaching services. I showed up for that group because it mattered to them.
Whether I grieved her passing right away or later changed nothing. But in that moment, I could make a difference for someone else.
As I sat next to her, I didn’t question whether I’d done it right. I didn’t wonder if I’d said everything or gotten the timing perfect. I knew I had shown up fully.
The last day I saw her, I asked her for one favor. “When you get to heaven, if you’re allowed to send me a message, can you let me know if God really looks like Morgan Freeman?” She laughed. She must not be allowed to send messages, because I still don’t know.
Annemarie is the reason I show up fully every day. I hope she’s the reason you do too.
Resources and Links Mentioned
-
-
-
-
- Sort everything on your plate with the free Capacity Decision Guide: consciousedge.com/decision. If you heard this talk live at InvestHer Con, consciousedge.com/ic26 takes you to the same guide.
- Instagram: @aleciastg. Send me a DM with the word “capacity,” and I’ll send you my favorite podcast episode on capacity.
- LinkedIn: Alecia St. Germain. Let’s connect.
-
-
-

